But I say this: Compare this Halloween to Halloween’s 3 through 8 and you’ll find that this is, at the very least, better than those. Some will probably enjoy it more than 2. It’s a tough film, in that if you’ve never seen Halloween, it’s new and who knows how you feel. If you have seen Halloween, like we have, I like to consider it exactly what it is – a different way of telling the same story. And for me it worked. I understand it didn’t work for everyone.

But I say this: Compare this Halloween to Halloween’s 3 through 8 and you’ll find that this is, at the very least, better than those. Some will probably enjoy it more than 2. It’s a tough film, in that if you’ve never seen Halloween, it’s new and who knows how you feel. If you have seen Halloween, like we have, I like to consider it exactly what it is – a different way of telling the same story. And for me it worked. I understand it didn’t work for everyone.

I find it more than hard to believe that you would give this piece of trash a B- … seriously … The first 15 minutes of this film might be the worst written and performed sequence in the last five years of cinema. The last half is a travesty to anyone familiar with the brilliant original.

The film fails on its own merits, but it aborts when compared to the original.

A B- ????? No fucking way … not EVER.

http://www.therecshow.com

I find it more than hard to believe that you would give this piece of trash a B- … seriously … The first 15 minutes of this film might be the worst written and performed sequence in the last five years of cinema. The last half is a travesty to anyone familiar with the brilliant original.

The film fails on its own merits, but it aborts when compared to the original.

A B- ????? No fucking way … not EVER.

http://www.therecshow.com