Movie Review
300 (Exclusive Early Review!)
Posted by El Bicho (elbicho@filmschoolrejects.com) on February 13, 2007
Brothers and sisters, lend me your eyes so I many share with you all the tale of brave Leonidas I, King of Sparta, son of King Anaxandridas II, descendant of Heracles, who led 300 Spartan warriors against the seemingly unending forces of Emperor Xerxes of Persia at The Battle of Thermopylae in 480 BC.
Xerxes sent forth messengers to all Greek city-states offering gifts in exchange for their surrender and allegiance. Leonidas did not take the insult kindly and in a breach of protocol killed the messengers. In accordance with Spartan law, he sought permission from the keepers of the oracle to go to war. He was denied, which he knew spelt disaster for his people. Although unable to rally the Spartan army, he skirted the law by gathering 300 warriors for a walk that coincidentally set out towards the mountain pass known as The Hot Gates, which is the only way Xerxes’ army could approach Sparta. While Leonidas is away and the battle rages on, Queen Gorgo works to convince the Spartan Council that the army needs to be discharged.
300, is an adaptation of the graphic novel written and drawn by Frank Miller with colors by Lynn Varley. Miller was inspired to chronicle this historical event after he saw the film The 300 Spartans as a young boy. From his vision, co-writer/director Zack Snyder has created a magnificent ballet of violence and bloodshed that is truly exquisite to behold. It’s not a glorification, but rather a hyper-realistic representation of a necessary evil that good men are forced to practice to live free. Not since the films of Sam Peckinpah has killing looked so good on the big screen.
Leonidas, played valiantly by Gerard Butler, is a proud King whose men worship him. He leads from the front, at the point of attack, unlike many leaders and rulers ever since who have hurled commands from the safety of being out of range. Leonidas’ military decisions have an immediate impact on him as well as those who serve alongside, allowing him to fully understand the price to be paid, and a mutual respect to flourish. During one battle, an injured soldier tells Leonidas it was an honor to die serving him. Leonidas informs the soldier it was an honor living beside him.
The film is filled with CGI throughout, recreating Miller’s drawings and Varley’s color palette and making possible all the stabbing, slicing, and blood squirting of the battle scenes. While obvious at times, especially the latter effect, the pace and artistry of the activity on the screen keeps the viewer engaged.
As brilliant as all the effects work is, the story and performances are what lift the film into rarefied air. A special kudos goes out to the actors’ training staff because the Spartans are extremely fit and every muscle is on display. The film is also augmented by the music of Tyler Bates, a fantastic mix that combines classical and metal elements, and includes the vocal work of Azam Ali.
The villain Xerxes is the film’s one flaw. All his dialogue is dubbed poorly, taking the viewer out of the moment and removing the menace his character should have created. The scene when he is alone with Leonidas the effects don’t work well. He looks where Leonidas is supposed to be and not at him.
The bar for sword-and-sandal epics has been set so high not even Icarus would attempt to reach it. Run with the speed of Hermes, and see 300 on the biggest screen with the best sound system available to better engulf your senses in its brilliance. I’m ready to relive it and rare is the film that compels me to see it again on the big screen.
Solace in Cinema offers a comic-to-screen-comparison for fans.
For those interested in learning the full story of the event, read Herodotus’s Histories.
Also, stay tuned in the coming days here at Film School Rejects for more on 300, including an Exclusive Interview with Director Zach Snyder!
Read more articles by El Bicho
5 Comments
February 13th, 2007 at 5:00 pm
I totally agree with this review. In reference to the comment about Xerses…Part of the problem was that Gerry Butler (Leonidas) is taller than the actor playing Xerses. In an attempt to make Xerses appear bigger, the effects were not as believable as the rest of the film was.
Indeed, the actors did have to put in an extraordinary effort to get into “Spartan shape”! Check the March issue of MENS HEALTH MAGAZINE with Gerry Butler on the cover. It goes into some detail about the training regimine they undertook. The official “300″ site has a video diary of the training that they were put through. And I do agree with the review further, about the final result on the screen. The movie would not have been nearly as believable if they had pot bellied and flabby Spartans.
February 13th, 2007 at 11:46 pm
How can you not be excited about this flick?
I had a chance to talk with Director Zach Snyder, and let me tell you that this film gets more and more exciting the more I hear about it. To quote it’s creator, it is just a hardcore ride!
March 11th, 2007 at 1:26 am
THAT is the film’s ONLY flaw?? How about the relentless and totally unrealistic CGI, which robs the film of any emotional weight needed for the film and its story to resonate?
A movie is comprised of still pictures run at 24 fps. Each individual picture could be a work of art, but if it’s run, it had better add up to a hell of a lot more than pretty pictures.
April 5th, 2007 at 11:02 am
This film was sometimes pretty but mostly war propaganda.
April 17th, 2007 at 10:33 pm
I dont understand how someone can call this movie war propaganda, since it is based on a comic book created BEFORE the war. Also since you opened the door, Ill say this for you, if our leader willing to sacrifice half as much as King Leonidas then America would be in better shape. But hes a fictional character and this is a fictional movie. SO I BEG ALL OF YOU quit calling it movie with political messages.