Michael Caine Gives Weight to Batman 3 Casting Rumors

Posted by Neil Miller (neil@filmschoolrejects.com) on September 8, 2008

If there is one thing that summer gave to fall in 2008, it was the gift of casting rumors. The late-July release of The Dark Knight and its subsequent historic box office run has paved the way to what can only be described as a avalanche of speculation that has rained down upon the internet, and has been greeted by thunderous outcries from fanboy and fangirl alike.

And while we’ve seen just about everything we thought we’d never see — from Cher as Catwoman to Milo Ventamiglia as Robin — the folks at Warner Bros. continue to remind us that Christopher Nolan hasn’t even decided to do another movie, let alone choose cast for one. But as always, that could change on a dime — especially if loose-lipped executives continue to chat with the equally loose-lipped Michael Caine. Caine told MTV News that he’s had conversations with higher-ups about the next film, and that they’ve already got some plans laid out:

“I was with [a Warner Bros.] executive and I said, ‘Are we going to make another one?’ They said yeah. I said, ‘How the hell are we going to top Heath? And he says ‘I’ll tell you how you top Heath — Johnny Depp as The Riddler and Philip Seymour Hoffman as The Penguin.’ I said, ‘S–t, they’ve done it again!’” [Laughs]

Johnny DeppAs the article over at MTV points out, the rumors around Johnny Depp and Philip Seymour Hoffman have been hot topics around the next Batman film for some time, emerging not too long after The Dark Knight was released. So far, these are the only casting rumors that have endured to the point of having a principal cast member talk about them — as Caine just did.

That said, it wouldn’t be prudent for fans to get their hopes up too much, as no official word has come down the pipe that the movie is even happening. And no matter how illogical it would be for WB or Chris Nolan to pass on the opportunity to continue the series, we can’t rule that out as a possibility. Having said that, the prospect of adding talent like Depp and Hoffman to a franchise that is already at the top of its game would be a great move, no matter the direction they choose to take with the characters. In a franchise that has been built on putting great talent in places where we may not have expected to see them, these two seem to be very plausible moves — that is, if they turn out to be true.

What do you think about Michael Caine’s comments — is he just feeding the rumor machine, or is he giving us some valuable insight?


Read more articles by Neil Miller

Related Reading:

Your Ad Here

Comment Policy: No hate speech allowed. If you must argue, please debate intelligently. Comments containing selected keywords or outbound links will be put into moderation to help prevent spam. Film School Rejects reserves the right to delete comments and ban anyone who doesn't follow the rules. We also reserve the right to modify any curse words in your comments and make you look like an idiot. Thank You!

  • Trace
    So long as whoever they cast puts in the time and dedication that Heath did, I'm game.
  • Jeremy M
    I think Caine is feeding the rumor machine.

    I really hope they stop multiplying villains in sequels. each villain should have his own shot
    at a movie. Unless they have a brilliant way to tie two villains together they should be left
    alone. The mixture of twoface and the joker was well done because twoface wasn't the
    character everyone emotionally invested in. Harvey Dent was. And he wasn't really a 'villain'.
  • Will Emero II
    Ugh - two of the worst Batman villains. What poor choices. I hope these are just rumors and slight-of-hand. Otherwise, the franchise is heading into Schumacher territory.
  • HempKnight757
    Sounds good to me they both could def. kill the parts just as long as Depp doesn't come off like he did in Secret Window more funny than scary & Phillip doesn't shart himself again or however its spelled.
  • Jason
    I think both could be awesome in the roles. I was watching 'The Prestige' the other day, and as you may know Andy Serkis (Gollum) is in it, and I thought he could play an interesting Riddler. Who knows.
  • Sam
    I love Hoffman, I just don't know about The Penguin character for the Nolanverse.

    I think I made an argument before (and other people probably have) that the Riddler makes sense as a villain if he's turned into a serial killer, and not some silly guy in tights who does way too much coke.
  • Sam, as a guy in tights who does way too much coke, I'm offended. This is an outrage.
  • Sam
    Well, Cole, I think we can probably find you a place in the live action ambiguously gay duo as a consolation prize.
  • JMoney
    i agree with Sam, the penguin can't really fit into this realistic Batman universe, i don't think people really want to see a movie about a flipper baby.

    But the Riddler could work as a serial killer, but I'm not convinced Depp would be good in the role, sometimes he is too over the top for me, and it would be hard to reign him in. The riddler would have to be very dark and i cant see depp pulling it off
  • I wouldn't count out Depp as the Riddler, I think he could handle that part pretty well. He has a lot of range and experience playing creepy characters in films.

    But I agree with Sam about turning him into a serial killer, Jim Carey's Riddler was idiotic at best, just some fruit loop in tights who looked zonked out on coke most of the time.
blog comments powered by Disqus