Discuss: Do You Want Sean Connery to Come Back for ‘Indy 5′?

Posted by Dr. Cole Abaius (cole.abaius@filmschoolrejects.com) on September 22, 2009

SeanConneryHenryJones

In what reads like a fanboy fantasy that someone wrote up as a news story, Moviehole is claiming that “a source” says that George “Lucas” and Steven Spielberg have “written” Henry Jones into their “script” for Indiana Jones and the Soich for More Money.

Of course, Moviehole is wise enough to report it as a massive rumor (and possibly a fanboy fantasy) and point out that Dr. Jones died according to dialog in Indiana Jones and the Crystal Skull. Spookily, the fictional Dr. Jones died at the age of 79 which is exactly how old Sean Connery is.

Unluckily, Ireland Online (I know, they got the entire country on the internet) is reporting this thing as if its news since they originated the story with the totally unnamed source. However, it gives us something interesting to think about.

Would you want to see Sean Connery come out of retirement for a small part in the next Indiana Jones movie?

Obviously there would be problems beyond those already mentioned, but isn’t the thought of having Indy get insulted by his old man cool enough to get past them? I would hope so, but it would feel cheap and forced if they brought him out, explained away his supposed death, then had him wave goodbye. He’d need to join them for the adventure somehow, or show up later on as a surprise figure with the information they needed to continue on with the quest, or appear up in the sky as a ghost that gives Indy hope and beard-trimming advice.

What do you think?


Read more articles by Dr. Cole Abaius

Related Reading:

Your Ad Here

Comment Policy: No hate speech allowed. If you must argue, please debate intelligently. Comments containing selected keywords or outbound links will be put into moderation to help prevent spam. Film School Rejects reserves the right to delete comments and ban anyone who doesn't follow the rules. We also reserve the right to modify any curse words in your comments and make you look like an idiot. Thank You!

  • Bring him back. The last one was a mess so who gives a shit about anything? EMO CUTTING BEGINS.

    But seriously. Bring him back. Maybe even make it the whole point of the movie. They THOUGHT he was dead because he went on a solo expedition and word came back he died. Indy pulls a Henry Stanley and finds him. OR Henry Sr. just turns up, having faked his death in search of some ultimate macguffin, which he almost got, but now its up to Junior to find.

    There. Lucas, that one's on the house.
  • I don't even want to see Indy return for Indy 5.
  • Icarus II
    Is it still cool to hate on Indy 4? Well, I'm ready to move past that, but no, I don't want Connery in Indy 5 even if it were just a quick flashback scene. I don't want to be reminded that TWO screen legends are nearing death. Just the one was more than enough in Indy 4.
  • Aleric
    I have to agree with Rob. Connery has been used in the past to try and save projects and they have been more miss than hit. I would rather see a well written, finely directed Indy movie myself, but Lucas and Speilberg will be involved so there goes that idea.
  • Christopher_M
    I'm sure they could say that Henry Jones Sr. faked his death so he could evade capture during another one of his adventures...It would be a good way to have fans look forward to an Indy 5...I mean man-eating ants, aliens and nuke the fridge scenes have become a swan song for the quality of the franchise....anything could be a step up if they go with a script not written by Lucas...I can only dream that Peter Jackson's relationship with Spielberg is strong enough that Jackson could be allowed to write and direct Indy 5.....considering their work together on Tintin which are similar in spirit

    I'd personally love to see an Indiana Jones script written by Edgar Wright and directed by Peter Jackson, does anyone else think this make for a better film?
  • I know I'm the minority here, but I actually liked Indy 4. It wasn't cinematic brilliance, and was certainly the weakest in the series, but it was still a pretty good movie, and I though it was good, bordering on great even sometimes. With this being said, I think they should either stop here (Indy gets married. If that's not the ending of a series, I don't know what is) or use the cards they've delt themselves. Don't go back to re-hashing old plot threads. You killed Henry Sr. Let a sleeping dog lie.

    Of course, none of this is probably true. Also, Tarzan Shia almost made me cry.
  • ladyofthelake
    Didn't Connrey retire because of his health? Whatever reason I don't want to see him back. Let him enjoy his retirement.
  • chrisgalea
    Get Sean Connery back!!!! and have it set before crystal skull so that we dont have to watch another indiana jones movie with Shia. Crystal Skull wasnt bad but seriously Shia and Harisson Ford together again NO WAY
  • Harrison and Steve
    ive said this a 1000 times and ill say it again. the best cinema ever in history
    would be "indiana jones and the hollow earth" , where Ford and Connery set out to
    find it only to find Hitler and his armies preparing another world tour. and the Hitler
    must be the same one(gordon brown)from all those youtube spoofs of the scene from
    'Downfall' this type of spielberg indy movie would easily double the boxoffice of The dark
    knight/titanic.

    lose Shia & pay Connery whatever he wants. you will make it back tenfold.
  • jennifersolis
    definetly with shia, and harrison without him this movie will bomb!
blog comments powered by Disqus